Mary (Spoiler)

Post by **Disciple of Claudia** » 19 Dec 2005

I know Mary didn't die 3 years ago, but I can't remember if she died 3 days or 3 weeks before James went to Silent Hill. I don't have immediate access to this information. I have a theory involving Mary but it hinges on when she died in order to have some weight to it. So if one of you would be so kind as to answer, pretty please.

P.S. Claudia is not part of this theory.

Post by **alone in the town** » 19 Dec 2005

It's within a week. More than likely, it was less than 24 hours before the game.

Post by **Bad Guy** » 19 Dec 2005

Wasnt there a theory that she was in the trunk of James's car? Why was that?

Post by **alone in the town** » 19 Dec 2005

That's a pretty common belief, actually. I believe she's in the trunk.

Post by **Bad Guy** » 19 Dec 2005

Well yeah... But why? I dont thnk anything points to this..

Post by **Disciple of Claudia** » 19 Dec 2005

It's common because the In the Water ending is allegedly the true ending to SH 2 and the whole thing is in James head therefore needs to have Mary's body on hand.

Post by **Bad Guy** » 19 Dec 2005

I see....

Post by **alone in the town** » 19 Dec 2005

In Water is not the true ending.

Mary's body is actually only seen in one ending, Rebirth. It's proof enough for me.

Post by **Bad Guy** » 19 Dec 2005

Hm. I need to get that one... Thats the one where you need the goblet, the chasm, the book, and I think theres one more thing...anyway, my job as the Hope House fell through. Skanks. But, the Brook Haven job looks spiffy!

Post by **Disciple of Claudia** » 19 Dec 2005

That it is. Now back to topic. I hear a week anyone else care to second this?

Anonymous · Post by **Anonymous** » 19 Dec 2005

Odds are, he had just murdered her.

Without disposing of it, I don't think a man can hide a dead body for long.

Also, in the Rebirth ending, Mary's head doesn't seem to be decomposed.

I'd almost say he killed her earlier that day/the day before.

She hasn't been gone long enough for anyone to realize she's dead. Frank thinks she and James went to Sh and just vanished.

Post by **Disciple of Claudia** » 19 Dec 2005

It was earlier than that.

Post by **Harrys_Girl** » 20 Dec 2005

Adversary has told us before,it is like March 13 and Jmaes goes to silent Hill on march 14.so something close to that.I has only been a day at the longest that she has been dead.

Post by **Room312** » 28 Dec 2005

wasn't the going theory that it was 3 days before the events?

EDIT

Nevermind. Dumb post. It was less than 24 hours....I just saw the Rebirth ending again, and her head looks just dandy.

Post by **PaintxThisxRed** » 28 Dec 2005

on which system did you just see the rebirth ending again? i have the ps2 version and i totally don't remember a thing.

Post by **Room312** » 28 Dec 2005

I just downloaded a video off Limewire, I didn't feel like earning it.

Post by **The Adversary** » 28 Dec 2005

She died on May 13th, 1994. The game occurs on May 14th.

Post by **Disciple of Claudia** » 29 Dec 2005

Thank you, you've all been very helpful.

Post by **inadvertence** » 10 Feb 2007

I've only gotten to the hospital, so I wouldn't know because I don't spoil it for myself. But I have accidently stumbled upon proof that James killed Mary.

But..do you think Mary is really in the trunk of Jame's car?
And why did James really murder her? Just curious.
I know he probably did because he wanted to end her suffering..but do you think there could have been another reason? Remember, I didn't finish the game so, forgive me if this was clarified in the game. =/

Post by **inadvertence** » 10 Feb 2007

Nevermind, I got some info off of a different site. XD