Silent Hill Heaven

So now you're talking about the amount of time between the shift and the significant plot event? I can beat Otherworld Brookhaven Hospital in less than 10 minutes. All you have to do is go to the basement to find Maria, grab the ring down there, then open the fridge with her to grab the other ring, ...

1) In the novelization, it wasn't a dream, making it possible that Cybil saved Harry from the monsters in the alleyway and brought him back to Cafe 5to2. 2) After the Kaufmann sidequest and before Harry meets Dahlia in the lighthouse, although this is where Dahlia fools Harry, so you can just drop t...

I forgot about that. Point taken, nice work.

Here are my examples (not that it really matters much):

- Harry in the alleyway in SH1
- Harry in the resort area in SH1
- Hilltop Center in SH3
- Lakeside Amusement Park in SH3

Remember the chain of events. She has to ask James "You're here to find Mary, aren't you, James?", then "She's here, isn't she?" as if she doesn't truly know herself. This is said in the Lakeview Hotel. I'm talking about her original motivation to go to Silent Hill, before she me...

I wasn't trying to "instigate shit", I was just saying I thought he had a legitimate point and thought saying it was "ass-backwards" was inappropriate. Look, I'm sorry, but I genuinely don't see how "Mary stayed at Brookhaven" makes the place "less significant"...

Furthermore, why is it even necessary for people to want her to have had to stay at Brookhaven? It's kinda redundant and cheapens some of its symbolism. This has to be one of the most ass-backwards things I've ever heard. The rest of your post just makes me think you haven't actually read the theor...

I've proved Misty Day is unreliable at the very least, which is good enough for me, personally.

You can believe whatever you want. To me, it shows Misty Day isn't historical and makes it less probable for the Valtiel sect to wear metal helmets.

NanayaShiki wrote: it doesn't change the fact that it could be a different creature than the Pyramid Head in SH2, just like Homecoming.

If it looks like a duck, swims like a duck, quacks like a duck, and is called a duck, we have no reason to believe it's a duck.

#Nanaya logic

The developers of The Arcade spent lots of time copying the textures, constructing the models, building wire-frames, etc. Even the wallpaper is the same, as well as all the other photos. I think it's very intentional. If the painting was real, it would be what James sees, but it isn't. It's safe to ...

The same game also uses Movie Version Pyramid Head. Wrong. His name is Red Pyramid Thing, and he wears gloves, isn't shirtless, has visible boots, and his helmet has 3 sides facing the front rather than 2. His knife is also his SH2 one with the white-edged blade, rather than the monochrome single-c...

It retains the atmosphere James remembers http://images3.wikia.nocookie.net/__cb20120203132856/silent/images/2/2f/Hunger.jpg http://images1.wikia.nocookie.net/__cb20090426070658/silent/images/9/9c/SH2Rosewater4.jpg I'd argue that the atmosphere of the park is completely different and doesn't retain...

Then let's just drop the "attitude" whole thing then and never mention it again. And I admit I first used stupid because I think executing someone wearing a heavy metal helmet is ridiculous, but whatever. Me saying that you seem a little rusty isn't "you're extremely ignorant and have...

Oh hey, Cyrus, didn't expect you to respond. (still a quote machine I see) And thanks. When I feel ready, I'm going to bring stuff from this topic over to the wiki but I still need to tie up some loose ends here. You're calling people's ideas stupid and the people themselves ignorant, and, well... D...

And you say you're not being hostile. I'm not being hostile, I just think your point is well, in your own words "stupid." You think everything I say is hostile, but I think you're just being too paranoid. I'm not trying to throw a wrench at you or anything, but provide some examples. 1) E...

Is the painting real? It is in a place with other paintings. It has an actual title and represents a real event. So we're talking about Misty Day now? No, Misty Day in a place with other photographs . It's a macabre painting among average looking real-life photos which to me is very out-of-place. B...

supernatural shenigans You mean shenanigans. And I don't think it's a good point at all. Silent Hill is a supernatural series. Weird stuff can still happen in the real world, such as the subway ghost and the mannequin room in SH3. There's also the entire mall level of SH3 (prior to Heather's elevat...

Does Travis have to necessarily be in the Otherworld for strange stuff to occur? I don't think so. Even if the painting exists, I don't know why we should treat it as historical, and not as an easter egg or a psychological mindtrick. Anyhow... Many other things in the Historical Society are familiar...

You literally said "I am right and you are wrong and if you disagree then deal with it". I did not. (denies) And I am not the only person who have pointed this out to you, so it's clearly not me. Cyrus and Ryantology never told me to stop being so hostile, and I had an epic debate with Cy...

Alex does seem to have toned the hostility and authoritative tone. Are you kidding me? What did I say in my previous post that was the least bit hostile? Seriously, stop trying to make me look like a tyrant. It's not me, it's you who sees me this way. Maybe you're just looking at my Alex Shepherd a...

you've demonstrated a severe lack of research-conducting I only asked for a link to an interview, and now all of a sudden I don't do my research? Just because I disagree with some statements here, it doesn't mean I don't do my research. It just means I do not believe your "proof" is "...