For me, I got the Bad+ ending first. And it really wasn't all that bad.

Bad ending first. lol I was dissapointed!

I always got Bad and Bad+ mixed up.

i got the good+ ending because i paid attention to the guide... beautiful ending. cybil and harry raise the child.

^Guides are for the weak!

I'm my own guide <This sounded so cool>

I only use Guides to knwon about Endings
Other then that no Guide for me
I play way to meany games to replay them alot *sametimes I do for good games and when theres good resson to do it again*
So Most time I go for best ending and go on

I got Good+

Once sat down in game stop to read SH2 guide....

Bad+ But my second play I got Good+ So not that bad. Oh and Juanfir your sig is a little to big 100x100 are the limits<3

Bad.... And I just don't find playing any game twice through to be as exciting / worth the second effort. (except original mario bro games and the such which took like an hour). I have many more games that I need to play first since I like to buy in bulk at the game stores. But yeah, ever since that Bad occurance, I made sure I was careful and concentrated harder on the details and exploring for all sidequests.

I got Good as my first ending, because I didn't use a guide.

You can tell who did, because they got + endings on their first attempts.

What sucker would use a Guide book?
There all shity now and days
I here the DQ8 one really blows XD
Poor guy

I got the bad ending then the bad+ ending. I only use the guide if I'm really really stuck. but i completed the game over 14 times so i don't really have to worry for a guide.

I got the good ending the first time I played.

[spoiler] Is it just me or is the good ending and good + ending looks the same? [/spoiler]

Must just be you, because they have one massive, fundamental difference.

I didn't use a guide. I read about the Bosses and monsters before I got the game. So I knew,

[spoiler]To use the red water on Cybil[/spoiler]

That counts as using guidance, as far as I'm concerned.

Play it without any outside information, and you'll never get a + ending the first time.

I didn't mean to read it. It just, kinda came up. I didn't want to read it.

I'm not damning you for doing so.

The people who do annoy the hell out of me are those who claim to get a + ending completely on their own, with no help whatsoever, because every last one is a liar.

First, Bad and then Bad + second time. I have yet to see a good ending, but I'm working on it. I'm playing through again and I'm at the hospital so far.