Could Cynthia be pregnant?
Moderator: Moderators
- REDGRAVE65
- Just Passing Through
- Posts: 72
- Joined: 01 Jan 2010
- Location: Curry,Alabama
Could Cynthia be pregnant?
I looked for a thread like this but I couldn't find one. I was replaying 4 when I got to the scene where she's about to throw up. I noticed that a reason is never really given for why shes sick. She acts fine when Henry first meets her so it probably isn't from a hangover and she didn't seem to see anything disgusting yet. So the reason I think shes pregnant is because it fits her personality and her role in the 21 sacraments as a temptress. Cynthia doesn't really seem like the kind of person who would handle sex that safely does she? Well what do you think?
Anyone ever wonder how nice the real version of Silent Hill is?
Re: Could Cynthia be pregnant?
I think everyone noticed that she was sick but since it isn't quite relevant (i.e nobody cares about the secondary characters of The Room) people seem to don't think anything about the vomit.
Yeah, interesting theory but I don't think that's possible. No in-game evidence, you know. But it's fun to speculate. Sometimes it brings interesting, and refreshing things regarding the games.
Yeah, interesting theory but I don't think that's possible. No in-game evidence, you know. But it's fun to speculate. Sometimes it brings interesting, and refreshing things regarding the games.
- alone in the town
- Historical Society Historian
- Posts: 11108
- Joined: 15 Apr 2004
- Gender: Male
- Location: In the anals of forum history
- Contact:
Re: Could Cynthia be pregnant?
I believe you may have skipped over a few hundred less extreme possible causes for mild nausea.
- AuraTwilight
- Historical Society Historian
- Posts: 11390
- Joined: 01 Aug 2006
- Location: I'm here, and waiting for you
- Contact:
Re: Could Cynthia be pregnant?
Also, given the tremendous womb/pregnancy/motherhood themes throughout the game, it would've come up if it was at all the case.
[quote="BlackFire2"]I thought he meant the special powers of her vagina.[/quote]
Re: Could Cynthia be pregnant?
What everyone said, plus . . .
How does temptation fit into "pregnant chick puking in toilet"? I mean, I would get it if you mentioned Eileen, but Cynthia? There is nothing tempting about a pregnant woman who is about to puke. At least not to me, but . . . everyone their tastes.REDGRAVE65 wrote:So the reason I think shes pregnant is because it fits her personality and her role in the 21 sacraments as a temptress.
Re: Could Cynthia be pregnant?
^ I believe he said that, because of her role, she'd have plenty of people to mate with.
Therefore a lusty young woman who seduces and fucks everyone = pregnant at one point or the other.
Therefore a lusty young woman who seduces and fucks everyone = pregnant at one point or the other.
- REDGRAVE65
- Just Passing Through
- Posts: 72
- Joined: 01 Jan 2010
- Location: Curry,Alabama
Re: Could Cynthia be pregnant?
^Yeah thats what I meant.
Anyone ever wonder how nice the real version of Silent Hill is?
- alone in the town
- Historical Society Historian
- Posts: 11108
- Joined: 15 Apr 2004
- Gender: Male
- Location: In the anals of forum history
- Contact:
Re: Could Cynthia be pregnant?
A big part of the problem is that you're only assuming she's a slut.
The emphasis implies that she would not behave this way in real life.I'll do a "special favor" for you later...
It's just a dream, so I might as well have some fun...
Re: Could Cynthia be pregnant?
^ Yes, well. . . you can't blame it on him for the slut deduction. I mean, it's kinda obvious. Just look the way she dresses or watch her movement in front of the subway entrance, which is in the real world. I get what you're saying, from a very objective point of view there is no concrete evidence that she is a whore. It's rather an intuition thing. And when it's about slutty characters, I believe intuition plays a big role here. I think Cynthia's character was also intended to be conceived as a promiscuous type. I'm not sure if it was done to confuse us or not.
However, as I stated before, I also don't completely observe Cynthia as a massive infected blower. It depends on your point of view.
First of all, if you interpret the victims from 17 to 21, you'll see that all of them are fruit of their theme: Jasper would represent source, I'm not completely sure, but I believe he represents the source of evil, the demon, also implied by the figure on his shirt; the demon has to return to its source, which is hell- fire. Andrew represents watchfulness. Obviously, he was the one who watched. Richard was the source or chaos: he posesses a big scary gun, he scares little children with it and skinnes neighbours. As much as it regards victims 20 & 21, I don't have to explain: Eileen is the Holy Mother Reborn and Henry the Receiver of Wisdom.
Now that we've seen the scheme of the murder themes, it could be interpreted that Cynthia is also the fruit of her own theme/sin: temptation. The problem here is: 'Is she the temptress or the tempted one?'. If she's the tempted one, we can apply the pregnant slut theory. Viceversa, if she's isn't then a completely new viewpoint applies.
However, as I stated before, I also don't completely observe Cynthia as a massive infected blower. It depends on your point of view.
First of all, if you interpret the victims from 17 to 21, you'll see that all of them are fruit of their theme: Jasper would represent source, I'm not completely sure, but I believe he represents the source of evil, the demon, also implied by the figure on his shirt; the demon has to return to its source, which is hell- fire. Andrew represents watchfulness. Obviously, he was the one who watched. Richard was the source or chaos: he posesses a big scary gun, he scares little children with it and skinnes neighbours. As much as it regards victims 20 & 21, I don't have to explain: Eileen is the Holy Mother Reborn and Henry the Receiver of Wisdom.
Now that we've seen the scheme of the murder themes, it could be interpreted that Cynthia is also the fruit of her own theme/sin: temptation. The problem here is: 'Is she the temptress or the tempted one?'. If she's the tempted one, we can apply the pregnant slut theory. Viceversa, if she's isn't then a completely new viewpoint applies.
Re: Could Cynthia be pregnant?
^ Lol. Richard's theme isn't Chaos because he teases little kiddos with guns. It's because Richard is a very unstable man.
And "Skinned Mike" never happened the way some think it did. He just threw some punchs and kicks, nothing more.
Jasper's Source could be interpreted as knowledge. Who besides the Order (and it's members) cares about the Occult and Silent Hill's history? The only character that appeared with such traits is Jasper.
Andrew is pretty much irrelevant because it's already answered in-game. His duty was to bring the "Watchful Eye of the Demon" to Walter's world.
And "Skinned Mike" never happened the way some think it did. He just threw some punchs and kicks, nothing more.
Jasper's Source could be interpreted as knowledge. Who besides the Order (and it's members) cares about the Occult and Silent Hill's history? The only character that appeared with such traits is Jasper.
Andrew is pretty much irrelevant because it's already answered in-game. His duty was to bring the "Watchful Eye of the Demon" to Walter's world.
Re: Could Cynthia be pregnant?
And you missed my point. Richard, unstable or not, represents the holder of Chaos. Jasper, interpreted as a source of knowledge or a source of evil, he's always the source. Same goes for the rest. What I'm saying is that all of these victims are the subject of their theme themselves. And so, it creates kind of a problem when interpretating Cyinthia and her theme.
Plus, you don't need to be rude about it . . 'Lol'.
Plus, you don't need to be rude about it . . 'Lol'.
Re: Could Cynthia be pregnant?
^ You need to stop with assumptions about how people behave. That was a genuine form of expressing what I thought was funny. That Richard, by threatening people with guns, would receive the label CHAOS slapped in his forehead automatically. No questions asked, just for the sake of it.
You disregarding some theories because they're not your cup of tea is what is rude. And from what I checked, in recent days, you did it 3 times. Twice when the conversation was about Cynthia. Okay, I got it . You liked the slut. Can we move on?
And I don't see a problem about interpreting Cynthia's theme. Isn't it obvious? Do you even know why Walter killed her, or the others? He didn't killed random people, and the themes are not because the persons "held" them. He interpreted their meaning and placed them in such victims. Another obvious thing.
You disregarding some theories because they're not your cup of tea is what is rude. And from what I checked, in recent days, you did it 3 times. Twice when the conversation was about Cynthia. Okay, I got it . You liked the slut. Can we move on?
And I don't see a problem about interpreting Cynthia's theme. Isn't it obvious? Do you even know why Walter killed her, or the others? He didn't killed random people, and the themes are not because the persons "held" them. He interpreted their meaning and placed them in such victims. Another obvious thing.
- AuraTwilight
- Historical Society Historian
- Posts: 11390
- Joined: 01 Aug 2006
- Location: I'm here, and waiting for you
- Contact:
Re: Could Cynthia be pregnant?
I'm pretty sure that since Walter targeted people he personally wanted vengeance on, he bullshitted justifications after the fact.
[quote="BlackFire2"]I thought he meant the special powers of her vagina.[/quote]
Re: Could Cynthia be pregnant?
^ I'm not saying you're wrong but Walter didn't had any personal vendetta with Jasper's friends, the old lady Sharon, Billy and Mirian Locane. To name a few.
Course vengeance was a major factor that drived him but he studied (at least some) of his victims.
Course vengeance was a major factor that drived him but he studied (at least some) of his victims.
- The Adversary
- RESPECT
- Posts: 20095
- Joined: 19 Jul 2003
- Location: #lfk
- Contact:
Re: Could Cynthia be pregnant?
Walter killed Bobby and Thane because they were too close to knowing "the devil" in him. He also seemed to believe Jasper knew too much about him, being an almost-witness.
Conflicting stories exist regarding Sharon Blake. One claims she worked at Wish House. Another claims her child was kidnapped and she went to find her. Walter probably didn't know either story was true—what's important to him is how he, and Valtiel, judge the victim. It doesn't matter whether or not the victim is actually guilty of anything. With Valtiel in Walter's subconscious, being the ultimate judge, he's free to kill whoever he wants and it will "count" toward the ritual.
That's how Walter got away with killing the Locane kids, in spite of him feeling great remorse for doing it.
Regarding Cynthia, Walter labeled her Temptation because, as a young man, he watched her grow up in Ashfield and ultimately believed she had been tempting him, seducing him. She always seemed to be where he was, and Walter was batshit sociopathically insane enough to believe she was following him.
Conflicting stories exist regarding Sharon Blake. One claims she worked at Wish House. Another claims her child was kidnapped and she went to find her. Walter probably didn't know either story was true—what's important to him is how he, and Valtiel, judge the victim. It doesn't matter whether or not the victim is actually guilty of anything. With Valtiel in Walter's subconscious, being the ultimate judge, he's free to kill whoever he wants and it will "count" toward the ritual.
That's how Walter got away with killing the Locane kids, in spite of him feeling great remorse for doing it.
Regarding Cynthia, Walter labeled her Temptation because, as a young man, he watched her grow up in Ashfield and ultimately believed she had been tempting him, seducing him. She always seemed to be where he was, and Walter was batshit sociopathically insane enough to believe she was following him.
This post is the property of its author and is not to be used elsewhere without explicit permission from the author.
. . . AND THAT'S THAT.
. . . AND THAT'S THAT.
Re: Could Cynthia be pregnant?
^ Isn't there a story about him talking with Cynthia in one of the stations of the subway and she made him look bad or something?
And to be fair, he could've picked anyone at the Ten Hearts part because he only needed the organs. No big deal. But once he killed himself it seemed his connection with Valtiel became stronger and made him actually think about his victims' behaviours.
And to be fair, he could've picked anyone at the Ten Hearts part because he only needed the organs. No big deal. But once he killed himself it seemed his connection with Valtiel became stronger and made him actually think about his victims' behaviours.
- The Adversary
- RESPECT
- Posts: 20095
- Joined: 19 Jul 2003
- Location: #lfk
- Contact:
Re: Could Cynthia be pregnant?
>Isn't there a story about him talking with Cynthia in one of the stations of the subway and she made him look bad or something?<
Cynthia embarrassed Walter by calling him out for being a creepster when he told her he'd been watching her for years. I don't blame her.
>he could've picked anyone at the Ten Hearts part because he only needed the organs.<
True, but what's important is that they were guilty, or made guilty, with the help of Valtiel as judge.
Cynthia embarrassed Walter by calling him out for being a creepster when he told her he'd been watching her for years. I don't blame her.
>he could've picked anyone at the Ten Hearts part because he only needed the organs.<
True, but what's important is that they were guilty, or made guilty, with the help of Valtiel as judge.
This post is the property of its author and is not to be used elsewhere without explicit permission from the author.
. . . AND THAT'S THAT.
. . . AND THAT'S THAT.
Re: Could Cynthia be pregnant?
^ Didn't Valtiel leave Walter's body after the Holy Assumption? So, after Billy and Miriam, it was Walter himself to choose his victims.
I think you should drop it, as I'm sure as hell I am.
Nevertheless, you quoted my text, a very ridiculous thought, while your rich explanation was that Richard had been an unstable man. Many folks in SH4 were mentally unstable, but that is not the reason of why themes were applied on them.Mephisto wrote:That Richard, by threatening people with guns, would receive the label CHAOS slapped in his forehead automatically
I don't want to comment anything about this nor am I flaming now. It really seems unnecessary from what I'm reading.Mephisto wrote:You disregarding some theories because they're not your cup of tea is what is rude. And from what I checked, in recent days, you did it 3 times. Twice when the conversation was about Cynthia. Okay, I got it . You liked the slut. Can we move on?
I think you should drop it, as I'm sure as hell I am.
Re: Could Cynthia be pregnant?
^ I meant unstable not by Angela/James standards if that's what you're trying to come up with. Rich's whole behaviour made him the harbinger of chaos. Confusion and destruction followed him pretty much everywhere inside the apartment building.
And most folks of The Room were trying to live their lifes like a normal human should. They had their manias (like everyone) but I don't think a large number of them were unstable...
When he commited suicide by performing the Holy Assumption and returned as a ghost, it seemed that he now had a true purpose. He wasn't aiming at random people anymore and didn't had anything controlling his thoughts. He (to quote Adversary) became the "judge". Therefore his connection with Valtiel was stronger.
Not saying this as a fact, more like a metaphor.
And most folks of The Room were trying to live their lifes like a normal human should. They had their manias (like everyone) but I don't think a large number of them were unstable...
Well, before actually. It was when Walter finished the Ten Hearts part and was sent to prison.Didn't Valtiel leave Walter's body after the Holy Assumption?
When he commited suicide by performing the Holy Assumption and returned as a ghost, it seemed that he now had a true purpose. He wasn't aiming at random people anymore and didn't had anything controlling his thoughts. He (to quote Adversary) became the "judge". Therefore his connection with Valtiel was stronger.
Not saying this as a fact, more like a metaphor.
- AuraTwilight
- Historical Society Historian
- Posts: 11390
- Joined: 01 Aug 2006
- Location: I'm here, and waiting for you
- Contact:
Re: Could Cynthia be pregnant?
Uh...there were two more Hearts after Billy and Miriam.^ Didn't Valtiel leave Walter's body after the Holy Assumption? So, after Billy and Miriam, it was Walter himself to choose his victims.
And even if such is that case, since the ritual is already underway, Walter still probably holds the authority to judge. He chose the victims ANYWAY, but Valtiel was basically going "Yup, that's legit."
[quote="BlackFire2"]I thought he meant the special powers of her vagina.[/quote]