Silent Hill Heaven

I made tihs in advance from "Mary and Maria"Poll from Easteralex so it already can be made.I voted for MAria and James because they seem perfect together.

Hmm I was going to made a Poll like this after Mary or MAry but since you made it thanks!I voted with Maria same with your comments

"The problem is... You're not Mary."

James & Maria!!!!!! Couple of psychos together.... what a perfect match!!!!

Why is Maria a psycho? Because of the ending?
I'd probably get a little beastly if the guy I liked kept calling me by his dead wife's name, too...


If anything I think Mary is a bit twisted for having helped create the world James is suffering in. Now, that’s retribution.

But marias not real though!! And did u play the scenario where ur maria on the special edition? That just proves shes got a few screws loose

I think Maria is everything that James wants, she's free in all the ways that Mary isn't, but she's also the damsel in distress and her whole existance is to be with James and dependant on him... "you're supposed to take care of me...."

Mary is herself, she's the one James fell in love with and married, yes she got sick.... but that shouldn't change things.

I don't know, is this a, would you have Maria if Mary never existed, or would you have Mary if Maria never existed kind of question? Or the... would you want Maria as a replacement type thingy?

whiter4bbit wrote:"The problem is... You're not Mary."

Exactly...
This can't even be argued.

Mary. James never really cared about Maria to begin with, except for the fact that she was a human being (and happened to look a lot like Mary)

James is an ordinary guy, rather. Better matching for him is Mary, since Maria is provoking as she's a boogie-woogie dancer. Not diffrently.

I can't figure how James & Maria could be a fitting pair, when Maria is a manifestation of James' unquenchable, carnal desires. It's like dating someone that walked outta your most recent issue of Hustler: likely to be undoubtedly fun for a while, but quickly gets old when lack of depth becomes apparent.

I vote for James & Mary, the real person. Like every other person, they are flawed individuals in their own rights.

yeah but forget the whole maria isnt real or the mary is dead or james is a psycho who likes to play with chainsaws and just think of it as who makes a better looking pair

James & Mary still, with reasoning similar to before (even after omitting the whole unreal/dead/psycho part).

I'd say maria and James.. I Liked the way they bonded in the game.. Plus we dont know much bout mary and james's relationship

Wow.....in the "Mary and Maria"Poll Maria is a winner but here Mary is the winner!

I vote James and Mary they are married afterall!

Well crud, I voted without thinking. I voted James and Mary, but would rather say James and Maria. Here's why: James does not deserve Mary. Yes, I know he did it because he didn't like to watch her suffer, but geez...come on. Maria is a slut and James is a psycho, they're perfect.

James and Maria? More like James and James... :K

And did u play the scenario where ur maria on the special edition?

Many times.

"The problem is... You're not Mary."

James and Mary, all the way. They are the truth, the couple that is in love, the other's reason for existence. Maria is merely in James way, tempting him from finding Mary. The only way he even shows that he cares for her in an intimate, loving fashion is when you, the player, elects to spend time with her and protect her. No matter what you elect to do, James still wants to find Mary, and to be with her. At least in my opinion, Mary is the only solution (unless you, the player wants it to be Maria.) However...