Mistakes

Post by **hummer** » 21 Apr 2006

did anyone notice any mistakes in the film at all, if so post some

Anonymous · Post by **Anonymous** » 21 Apr 2006

Other than the microphone that's poking into PH during the skinning scene?

No, I didn't notice anything. I'm going to see it again later today, so I'll start keeping an eye out for things like that.

Anonymous · Post by **Anonymous** » 21 Apr 2006

When Rose and Cybil enters the church for the first time and those fanatics ripped that chain from Rose's neck. I don't seem to remember Rose ever actually "wear" the necklace. Most of the time it was the mobile. But the main thing here is that we see them rip the necklace from Rose and the camera turns away. When the camera turns back on Rose, she had nothing around her neck. The camera turns away again and when it turns back to Rose (like 5 seconds later) we see her mobile around her neck! ROFL silly people let such a dumb mistake like that slip... When people makes simple mistake like that, it means they're either too tired of the movie now or don't care as much about it.

Well I guess they couldn't have her wear both her necklace and her mobile at the same time but then again, they didn't have to make her wear the mobile again. It was never used again anyway (only activated once when Rose was with Cybil and they met that monster and Cybil shoots it).

Also during that scene when Rose runs into the corridor with all those nurses, the mobile never activated! It was supposed to activate whenever there was monsters about. Well she could have switched it off which just goes to prove my point that she never needed to wear it again after the first activation.
If I was the director and asked about this, I know what I say. "er... it was... the er... the battery! Yeah thats right. The battery died!"

Well i hope you win whatever competition you plan on entering with this.

Post by **the man in the planet** » 21 Apr 2006

yeah, the phone should have gone off with the nurses.

Anonymous · Post by **Anonymous** » 22 Apr 2006

She turned the phone off.

The nurses were a trap that Christabella hoped would kill Rose.

Post by **the man in the planet** » 22 Apr 2006

well, it seemed like a pretty easy thing to get past for something so important. this was one of those places the challenge of a video game might have been more interesting. i thought the scene was great but was like, aw, that's it? and didn't she turn off the car radio and it still went nuts? minor point, tho. thought it was dumb she left the light there. how'd she know she wouldn't need it? and if other had gone down there before and not returned, wouldn't there have been bodies? felt very much like the spider scene in LOTR, them just waiting... in a good way.

Post by **Droo** » 22 Apr 2006

The Nurses weren't a trap per se. Christabella has no control whatsoever over Alessa's manifestations. She just knew that the hospital was Alessa's home, and that there would undoubtedly be something nasty down there to kill Rose.

Post by **kingscratchie** » 22 Apr 2006

Cybil did say that christiabella (sp) was trying to kill her, but i though how she knew she knew where alessa's room was located was odd.

Post by **Tank Girl** » 22 Apr 2006

FrozenHalo wrote:She turned the phone off.

The nurses were a trap that Christabella hoped would kill Rose.

Not necessarily. After all, when given the torch, Rose was told "Light will attract them, but without it you cannot see" or something like that - I may not have the wording right. So, if she really wanted to trap Rose... she wouldn't have been given that hint.

Post by **DocBlaze27** » 22 Apr 2006

Lmao at the jump cut in the PH scene... Rose takes the pipe and sticks it between the two walls on either side of the door to block it, but then it cuts to the door later on and the pipe is between the handles...

Post by **put_here_2_feel_joy** » 22 Apr 2006

I thought it was weird in the skinning of Anna (Loopie) scene, that PH ripped off all her clothes so she was naked, then when they showed him grabbing her skin, she had no breasts. Just a bare chest, or maybe it went by too quickly. But I'm pretty sure that she had nothing there... Not that I really wanna see her boobs, but I mean.. She has them, they shouldn't just disappear..
Did anyone else notice this?

Post by **DocBlaze27** » 22 Apr 2006

^^^Yeah I kinda noticed that too. Like you said, it was quick, but it looked as if she was flatchested...

Post by **put_here_2_feel_joy** » 22 Apr 2006

^^^I don't know, maybe they wanted to censor it a little bit? I mean boobs and blood splatter/spary might have been too much for the audience. lol

Post by **drgnrbrn316** » 22 Apr 2006

The door handle and the pipe wasn't really a mistake. For whatever reason, the handles were opened at the top. Pyramid Head couldn't pull the pipe up because the door had been bent down by his sword.

As for the locket, it was usually tucked under her shirt.

The lack of bodies in the basement? Did you see just how vast those maps were? Who's to say that they even made it to where the nurses were, or that they weren't dragged off?

Anonymous · Post by **Anonymous** » 22 Apr 2006

All I could really focus on was the sudden action of him peeling off her flesh then splitting her in half. It went by too quick to really make out anything distinctive except the flesh coming towards PH with his hand.

Post by **lovelytourniquet** » 22 Apr 2006

I think that the MPAA let them get away with a lot more than usual anyway so maybe nipples *gasp* would be too much.

Post by **DocBlaze27** » 22 Apr 2006

drgnrbrn316 wrote:The door handle and the pipe wasn't really a mistake. For whatever reason, the handles were opened at the top.

Are you positive? If I see it again, I'll make sure to take a look.

Post by **D90** » 22 Apr 2006

but i though how she knew she knew where alessa's room was located was odd.

Why wouldnt she know where Alessa was hospitlised? Being a relative, she could've easily gained that information.

seem to remember Rose ever actually "wear" the necklace

I'm pretty sure she has them both on all the time, its just that you dont notice the necklace because of the phone.

But I'm pretty sure that she had nothing there...

Was the shot not just too high for you to see them properly?
I was concentrating more on the whole grabbing and twisting thing.

Post by **lovelytourniquet** » 22 Apr 2006

drakan90 wrote:
but i though how she knew she knew where alessa's room was located was odd.
Why wouldnt she know where Alessa was hospitlised? Being a relative, she could've easily gained that information.

How is Cristabella related exactly? I don't remember is stating that.

Post by **Jonathan McEnroe** » 22 Apr 2006

Was reading a bit about the phone being turned off, remember the radio could be turned off in the games.