Silent Hill Heaven

I do.

What do *you* believe? Let's start there.

Okay, if you want to know the reasoning behind my opinion: It makes the overall storylines more clear, less convolted, and if characters were able to pull a " Groundhog's Day " type of ending, our opinions of which ones are canon are greatly different. This would most likely make Rebirth t...

Harrys_Girl wrote:SH1 took me just over 24hrs. to complete my first walkthrough at 10 yrs old and my parents help.

You played SH1 when you were 10 with your parents? That's awesome.

To answer this post, it took me 9 hrs. But that was because I spent a good hour or two exploring Silent Hill when I got there.

Agent, you're in luck. Somewhere in the media subforum, a guy actually made a full map of the whole city. I'll see if I can find the link for you. If you got $20 bucks to shell out, you can take this to a local printing factory and have them print a posterized version of this. I have one hanging and...

Heh, well if he reads this again, we'll know he's a moron

You posted in the wrong forum. This is the spoiler forum. Just for that, I'm going to punish you by telling you that Alex's dad gets cut in half, Judge Holloway gets drilled in the mouth, there are five endings and to trigger those endings you need to decided whether or not to save his mom, forgive ...

Not really. I'm just expressing an opinion. Last I checked, that was okay.

Really? You think Mary's not a construct? I agree that there's not much cases to base it on; but you gotta think eventually there's got to be some line of distinction between ghosts and figments and it might as well start close to those guidelines. Here's a question: Has Konami ever officially defin...

Krist. wrote:They're synonymous words, but okay. I'm too lazy to argue semantics.

White Castle and White Claudia?

There is no timeloop in the real canon. It's just thrown in there, along with the multiple endings, to suggest a philosophical possibility.

KageReneko wrote:Turn off your PS3 and play the disc in your PC, PS2 ofr PSX if you have any... The PC option is the easier, my first Silent Hill 1 play was in my PC cause I hadn't money for consoles in that time...

Fft. Gee thanx.

I'm going to be out of town without internet access for a few weeks. So don't think you've won ::shakes fist:: j/k I skimmed through the ghost comments and I just want to say that the term "ghost" has a wide range of definition in the SH-verse. It can range from something like Ernest to th...

That would be a good solution. I agree.

Personally, I think some info might have escaped their heads in Translated Memories. You make a very compelling case there and by no means is it a coincidence based on the pattern you've presented. A good find, my man. A good find.

I'm passionate about one thing though: The existance of Silent Hill 3 nullifies that the SH1 endings are interpretative. This isn't SH2.

No, it's the other way around. You (and others) brought up that statement before. I countered with a statement attributed directly to the scenario writer. I asked you if you could attribute your statement to a particular developer. You can't, of course. If my statement wasn't attributed to a partic...

Yes, and that's why a remake of SH1 with next-gen graphics is a big mistake. You get it.

Your comparison doesn't work because the Arcade is a new story. The novelette is based on the original game....No-one knows whether the Arcade is canon or not, but people can choose to ignore it because it doesn't relate much to the other stories. There's no danger in choosing to say that it didn't...

I'm only rude to those who are rude to me; I especially don't like that he's turned this " Good as canon " idea as if I was the one who came up with it. I was just a minor spectator in the crowd until he decided to choose me for whatever reason to debate on it. Similarly, I'm rehashing the...